SHOULD THE CATEGORY "HATE CRIME" BE ABOLISHED by The Justice of the Peace

SHOULD THE CATEGORY "HATE CRIME" BE ABOLISHED?

written by The Justice of the Peace on the 03^rd April 2017 at 12:39 - Posted in Police Blog

For England Wales and Scotland the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 made hateful behaviour towards a victim based on the victimâ€™s membership (or presumed membership) in a racial group or a religious group an aggravation in sentencing for specified crimes. Does it really justify increasing a proposed custodial sentence if the perpetrator made clear that his assault was motivated because the victim was a so called goth, or gay, or Muslim or Jew, or Hindu or whatever minority category the court recognised. Does the hate within the perverted personality of a viscous thug need to be eg of a non acquisitive nature? The examples are not infinite but I`m sure many can come readily to mind. The result of such criminal action up to and including murder is not altered by the offender`s reason assuming there is no defence of diminished responsibility. Some jurisdictions do not recognise hate crimes; Albania, Cyprus, Estonia, San Marino, Slovenia and Turkey.

The great and the good of this country`s legal establishment consider hate to be an aggravating factor. The simple reason I can think of is that by so doing they consider a certain but unknown amount of protection for the minorities and/or deterrence to the assailants is offered. But then why have a differential at all. If the sentence per crime were increased so that all were at the same level would that not be more logical? I doubt that those intending violence consider that shouting fucking Jew, Muslim, Queer or what have you will increase their sentence if convicted. They are so self centred and/or encompassed by their perverted passions that the thought of being in court just does not occur to their little minds. For the legal process the term "hate crime" can be in itself a source of some controversy. It is time to consider its abolition as an aggravating factor?

Similar Stories

Jake Newsome appears in court over Facebook message sent after death of Leeds Teacher Posted on 14^th May 2014
CCTV appeal following an affray in Stevenage Posted on 08^th December 2014
Police dog finds missing man from Hemel Hempstead ukcri.me/62492 Posted on 16^th June 2015
Appeal following theft from Argos in Borehamwood ukcri.me/62118 Posted on 06^th May 2015
CCTV appeal following an assault in Hemel Hempstead Posted on 17^th November 2014
CCTV appeal following robbery at Upholland pharmacy ukcri.me/61451 Posted on 27^th March 2015
CCTV appeal following theft in Watford Posted on 21^st January 2015
Appeal for witness to racist incident in Blackpool ukcri.me/61351 Posted on 23^rd March 2015
Handbag stolen from parked car in Cathays Posted on 19^th November 2014
TEDx Talk Posted on 27^th June 2017

Latest The Justice Of The Peace Police Stories

PHONING AT THE WHEEL NEEDS A RE-THINK
ANOTHER COURT INTERPRETER PROVIDER BITES THE DUST
CAMERON OR JOHNSON; WHAT`S THE DIFFERENCE?
HOW AWFUL
MUSINGS ON THURSDAY (2)