Crime And Punishment by The Magistrates' Blog

Crime And Punishment

written by The Magistrates' Blog on the 13^th May 2016 at 22:22 - Posted in Police Blog

For the last few weeks the media has given extensive coverage to the Hillsborough disaster. The release of the report saw emotionally charged interviews with the bereaved that were understandable, especially given the drama-soaked circumstances. It transpired, as so often happens, that some of those crying loudly for 'justice' had revenge in mind, and that led me to think about the justice that I help to administer. Seriousness and culpability come near the top of our list of things to consider, so let's take a cool-headed look at Hillsborough.
The police commander made an error of judgment in opening the gates to the terraces, a relatively low-level error but one that had devastating consequences. The response of he police and other services was inadequate, and many deaths resulted.
So what would be justice in this case, given the finality of all those corpses?

It appears that the police commander might be liable in law for negligence (although I am not at all qualified to comment on the legal aspects) but what good would it do to punish him?

The nearest parallel that I can think of is in the field of aviation safety. Pilots are able to report incidents fully and truthfully, without fear of being punished. This is by far the best way to build a body of experience to avoid future disasters.

However, and it is a massive however, there are suggestions that there was a cover-up at all levels, including, incredibly, the methodical editing of police statements. That is what should attract condign punishment, rather than one man's catastrophic failure of judgement.

Similar Stories

CRIME AND LACK OF PUNISHMENT Posted on 22^nd January 2016
400 criminals a week reoffend during community punishment Posted on 21^st August 2012
Five centuries of crime and punishment leave the Old Bailey in need of repairs Posted on 10^th June 2013
Victims of antisocial behaviour to decide on punishment Posted on 09^th October 2012
NO INSURANCE THEN WE`LL TAKE YOUR CAR Posted on 22^nd November 2016
Police cannot cut crime while this is going onâ€¦â€¦ Posted on 14^th December 2011
The Dummyâ€™s Guide To Privatisation/Outsourcing Posted on 26^th July 2015
PUBLIC PROTECTION AND PUBLIC PERCEPTION Posted on 09^th February 2017
NO NONSENSE AT LIVERPOOL CROWN COURT IN 2017 Posted on 09^th January 2018
BENCH GOT IT WRONG Posted on 12^th December 2017

Latest The Magistrates\' Blog Police Stories

Back to the Ranch
New Stuff
Dog Days
In The Nick
Supreme Chicken?